The Economics Of AI Answers: Google’s Earnings And Reddit’s Traffic

🔍 Read the full analysis: The Economics Of AI Answers: Google’s Earnings And Reddit’s Traffic on ThorstenMeyerAI.com

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Alphabet said Google AI Mode’s rapid query growth weighed on Search monetization, while still reporting that Search and other revenue rose 12% to $63.35 billion in the third quarter. The disclosure, made by business chief Philipp Schindler on October 28, came as Reddit CEO Steve Huffman said AI Mode does not drive traffic to websites, raising questions about how Google’s answer-style search affects publishers and other businesses that rely on visits from search.

Schindler was responding to an analyst who asked why Google searches grew at their fastest pace in five years while Search revenue growth slowed. He identified exchange rates as the largest factor in the deceleration relative to the prior quarter, followed by weaker spending from some Asia-Pacific retailers and normalized media spending after the football World Cup. He then said strong growth in AI Mode queries had an impact because of lower monetization in AI Mode. He did not quantify the revenue effect or say the product had reduced Search revenue overall.

That distinction matters: Alphabet’s reported Search and other revenue increased 12% in the quarter. The source material says the company did not provide a separate figure for AI Mode revenue or for the difference in revenue per query between AI Mode and standard search. Alphabet’s quarterly filing, submitted October 29, did not mention AI Mode; it attributed Search growth to query volume, advertiser spending and improvements to ad formats and delivery.

Alphabet shares fell 12.6% on October 29, their worst one-day decline since the company went public in 2004, according to reports cited in the source. Estimates of the resulting market-value loss ranged from about $475 billion to $500 billion. The same reports pointed to investor concerns beyond AI monetization: Alphabet posted free cash flow of minus $9.1 billion, compared with analyst expectations of roughly minus $2.7 billion, while quarterly spending on data centers and chips reached $51.4 billion.

The Cost of Answers Without Clicks

The economic tension is that an AI answer can satisfy a user’s question without sending that person to a website. If users click fewer links, publishers, forums and retailers may lose opportunities to earn advertising revenue, attract customers or build repeat audiences. Meanwhile, Google may earn less from an AI Mode query than from a conventional search, as Schindler’s remarks indicate. The effect on any one business will depend on its audience, search visibility and revenue model.

The source cites Chartbeat data showing Google Search’s share of pageviews across its publisher network falling from about 9% in July 2024 to 5% in July 2026. It also cites Pew research finding that users clicked a search result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, compared with 15% when it did not. Those figures describe different measures and should not be treated as a direct estimate of AI Mode’s effect on every publisher.

For Google, lower monetization per query could matter if AI Mode grows enough to change the mix of searches. The company’s stated response includes putting more ads within AI answers. For users, that could preserve a familiar way to find businesses, but it also leaves open how much of the answer experience will be advertising and how often users will visit the sources behind an answer.

Products Worth Considering

Logitech MX Keys S Wireless Keyboard, Graphite

AmazonView Latest Price

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Noise Cancelling Headphones, Sandstone

AmazonView Latest Price

LG 34GX90SA-W 34-inch Ultragear WQHD OLED Curved Gaming Monitor

AmazonView Latest Price

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

From Search Links to AI Responses

Google has described a broader increase in search activity alongside the growth of AI features. According to the source, the company said query growth was at its highest level in five years and that AI Mode queries were three times longer than traditional searches. Longer queries may reflect more detailed requests, but the earnings comments did not say how many such queries Google handles or how their revenue compares with standard search.

In July, Google said its AI features sent billions of clicks to websites each week. The October earnings call did not include a comparable traffic figure, leaving no company-provided update in the source material on whether that volume has changed. Reddit’s Huffman offered a contrary assessment, saying AI Mode does not drive traffic “not for us and not to anybody, as far as I know.” That is his view, not a published measurement of traffic across all websites.

The business model is also changing for online shops. The source says Google’s checkout standard covers “hundreds of thousands of brands,” pointing to a path for purchases that may not require a visit to a retailer’s own site. At the same time, policy scrutiny is increasing: the UK is requiring an AI opt-out, the European Union is investigating, and five French publisher groups filed a complaint on October 29. Google also pays more than 400 publications through a licensing pilot, according to the source.

“The strong growth in AI Mode queries had an impact because of the lower monetization we were seeing in AI Mode.”

— Philipp Schindler, Google’s business chief, on Alphabet’s October 28 earnings call

The Missing Traffic and Revenue Figures

Alphabet has not disclosed in the material cited how much less revenue an AI Mode query generates than a conventional search, how much the difference affected quarterly results, or what share of total Search activity AI Mode represents. Its filing also did not discuss AI Mode directly. Without those figures, Schindler’s comment confirms a direction of effect, not its size.

The traffic picture is also incomplete. Google’s July statement about billions of weekly clicks covered its AI features, while the October call supplied no updated figure. The Chartbeat and Pew measures cited here offer evidence of changing publisher traffic and user click behavior, but they do not establish a uniform effect across websites or isolate every cause of the changes. Huffman’s statement reflects Reddit’s assessment rather than independently verified traffic data for the whole web.

Finally, the share-price decline cannot be attributed to AI monetization alone. Reports cited by the source also link investor concern to Alphabet’s cash flow and large infrastructure spending. The available figures do not show how much each issue contributed to the October 29 market reaction.

More Data Will Test Google’s Model

The next useful evidence will be whether Alphabet provides figures on AI Mode’s revenue, advertising formats or referrals to outside websites in later earnings updates. Until then, investors and publishers will have to compare broad Search results with limited traffic indicators rather than a product-level account of the economics.

Regulatory and commercial developments may also shape how AI answers use and refer to publisher material. The UK opt-out requirement, the European Union investigation and the complaint filed by French publisher groups are ongoing matters cited in the source; their outcomes and any resulting changes to Google’s products are not yet established. Google’s licensing pilot and checkout standard will offer further indications of how it plans to compensate publishers and complete transactions within AI-driven search.

For now, the confirmed picture is narrower than some headlines suggested: AI Mode queries were growing and generated less monetization, but Google did not say that its Search revenue had fallen. That revenue grew in the quarter, while the scale of any lost website traffic and the longer-term balance between answers, ads and referrals remain unresolved.

Key Questions

Did Google say AI Mode caused Search revenue to fall?

No. Google said AI Mode’s growth had an impact because it was less monetized. Alphabet reported that Search and other revenue grew 12% to $63.35 billion in the third quarter.

How much revenue did AI Mode cost Google?

The source material gives no dollar estimate. Schindler did not quantify the monetization gap or the effect on quarterly revenue.

Does AI Mode send traffic to websites?

The evidence cited is mixed and incomplete. Google said in July that its AI features sent billions of clicks to websites each week, while Reddit CEO Steve Huffman said AI Mode does not drive traffic. The October earnings call included no updated Google traffic figure.

Why did Alphabet shares fall on October 29?

Alphabet shares fell 12.6%, their worst one-day decline since 2004, according to reports cited in the source. Those reports also pointed to negative free cash flow and high data-center and chip spending; the available material does not assign the decline to a single cause.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com