🔍 Read the full analysis: What The Disappearance Of Old Jobs Means In The AI Era on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
A November 2026 essay from ThorstenMeyerAI.com uses elevator operators, typists and typesetters to examine what past automation can—and cannot—tell us about AI. Its central finding, drawn from economist James Bessen’s study of 271 occupations, is that whole jobs rarely disappeared mainly because of automation, although task-focused roles could decline sharply. The essay cites a 2026 U.S. projection that office and administrative support jobs will shrink fastest by 2035, partly because of AI; the scale and distribution of future job losses remain uncertain.
A November 21 essay from ThorstenMeyerAI.com argues that past automation offers a mixed guide to AI-era job losses: whole occupations have rarely vanished because of machines, but jobs built around a narrow set of tasks can contract sharply. The account focuses on elevator operators, typists and typesetters, and cites a U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projection that office and administrative support employment will decline faster than other occupational groups through 2035, partly because of AI tools.
The essay draws on economist James Bessen’s 2016 study, which followed 271 detailed occupations recorded in the 1950 U.S. census through 2010. Bessen found that only one occupation in his analysis—elevator operator—had largely disappeared because of automation. Many other occupations faded for different reasons, including declining demand or the arrival of technologies that made their services obsolete. Bessen’s broader point was that automation usually takes over tasks rather than eliminating an entire job.
The essay contrasts that general pattern with word processors and typists, whose work was closely tied to producing text. U.S. employment in the occupation stood at 985,000 in 1988 and had fallen to about 40,400 by 2025, according to the figures cited in the article. It says the decline was much steeper than forecasters expected: a predicted 6% drop by 2000 compared with an actual 51% decline. The source material does not specify the exact forecast series or provide further methodology for that comparison.
For elevator operators, the essay links the occupation’s decline to the spread of automatic elevators, while cautioning against a popular account of how that change began. A 1945 New York strike by 16,600 elevator operators and other building workers across 2,100 buildings is documented in contemporary TIME coverage. But the essay says it found no document proving the strike caused building owners to install operator-free elevators. It reports that an automatic system without attendants was installed in a Dallas office building in 1950.
Infographic 01 · The number to remember
The one job automation wiped out
Elevator operators rose with the skyscrapers and fell with the automatic elevator. Of 271 occupations in the 1950 census, it is the only one that automation largely wiped out.
US elevator operators · census · thousands
Story vs. evidence
- Documented (TIME, 8 Oct 1945): 16,600 elevator operators and building workers on strike in 2,100 Manhattan buildings for five and a half days.
- Documented (Otis, company account): 1948 a recorded voice to help passengers trust automatic elevators; 1950 the first building with Otis high-speed, no-operator elevators (Dallas).
- Not documented: that the strike made owners switch to automatic elevators. A popular story; no source we found shows it.
Census figures: economically active persons 14 and over, each census in its own classification (1950 in the 1950 classification). Today the BLS publishes no separate count of elevator operators; installers and repairers are a different occupation.
Sources: US Census Bureau, Historical Statistics of the United States (1975), series D 233-682 (row D 587); J. Bessen, How Computer Automation Affects Occupations (2016); TIME, 8 Oct 1945; Otis company history; BLS Employment Projections 2025-35 (27 Aug 2026).
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
What Past Job Losses Tell Us
The history in the essay challenges two simple predictions: that new technology necessarily erases whole occupations, or that workers can expect every existing job to survive unchanged. Bessen’s study points instead to tasks as the main unit of change. Software or machinery can take over parts of a role while workers remain employed in work that still requires judgment, coordination or contact with other people.
That distinction matters because job titles can conceal very different exposure to automation. A role built around a limited, repeatable task may be more vulnerable than one combining many kinds of work. The typist example shows how a large occupation can contract over time when technology changes the way a core task is done. It does not establish that AI will produce the same outcome for today’s workers, but it shows why job counts and task changes need to be tracked separately.
The cited BLS projection puts office and administrative support at the center of the current concern, forecasting the group’s fastest decline among occupational groups through 2035 and identifying AI tools as one contributing factor. A projection is not a record of what has already happened, and it cannot by itself identify which workers will leave a field, move into different roles or find replacement work.
Products Worth Considering

Logitech MX Mechanical Wireless Illuminated Keyboard, Tactile Quiet, Graphite

LG UltraGear 34G600A-B 34-Inch Curved WQHD Gaming Monitor

LG 27GS60QC-B Ultragear 27-inch Curved Gaming Monitor (QHD, 180Hz, 1ms, 1000R)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Elevator Cars to Office Software
The elevator operator’s rise and decline unfolded over decades. U.S. census figures cited by the essay show the occupation growing from about 13,000 workers in 1900 to roughly 97,000 in 1950, before falling to about 77,000 in 1960 and 37,000 in 1970. Automatic elevators existed before attendants disappeared. The article says Otis offered recorded voice instructions in 1948 for its automatic Autotronic elevators while attendants were still present, reflecting the role of passenger reassurance as well as machinery.
The typist’s story followed a different pattern. Typewriters and expanding office work helped make typing a major occupation; the essay cites a rise from 134,000 stenographers, typists and secretaries in 1900 to 3.9 million in 1970. Word processors and personal computers later changed how text was produced. The third case, typesetting, shows workers contesting change: the essay says a three-week strike in Germany in 1978 helped keep text design in the hands of skilled print workers for a time. In 1998, the typesetter apprenticeship was merged into a new media-design trade.
These examples are drawn from a historical essay, not a new labor-market study. The article also notes that the BLS no longer counts elevator operators as a separate occupation. Its figure for elevator and escalator installers and repairers—about 24,700 jobs and a median annual wage of $109,910 in May 2025—describes a different occupation, not a surviving version of the operator role.
““In only one case—elevator operators—the decline and disappearance of an occupation can be largely attributed to automation.””
— James Bessen, Boston University economist, as quoted in the essay
How Much AI Will Change Employment
The historical examples do not settle how many jobs AI will eliminate, reshape or create. The essay reports a BLS forecast for office and administrative support through 2035, but a projection is not a confirmed outcome. The supplied material does not include the forecast’s exact employment-change percentage or a breakdown by occupation, so the scale of expected losses cannot be established here.
It is also unclear how quickly AI tools will spread across workplaces, which tasks employers will automate, or whether displaced workers will move into other occupations. The 1945 strike’s role in the replacement of elevator operators remains unproven in the account: the essay reports no document showing that the walkout caused owners to switch to automatic elevators. Its account of the strike as a trigger should therefore be treated as a popular explanation, not an established causal finding.
Tracking Work Through 2035
The next measurable point is whether employment changes match the BLS projection through 2035. Future labor-market data can show how office and administrative support employment changes, but totals alone will not reveal whether AI caused a shift or which tasks were affected. Researchers and workers will need to distinguish direct job losses from changed duties and movement into other roles.
For now, the historical comparison offers a way to frame the debate, not a forecast of a particular outcome. The key questions are which tasks AI systems take on, how employers reorganize work around them, and whether workers have routes into the tasks that remain or into new roles. The essay’s cases show that technological change can be gradual in some fields and severe for occupations centered on a narrow task; the pace and reach of AI’s effects remain to be seen.
Key Questions
Does the essay say AI will eliminate whole occupations?
No. It argues that previous automation usually changed tasks within jobs rather than eliminating whole occupations. It does not claim that AI will follow exactly the same pattern.
What does “1 of 271” refer to?
It refers to Bessen’s finding that, among 271 occupations in the 1950 U.S. census followed through 2010, elevator operator was the only one whose decline and disappearance he attributed largely to automation.
What happened to typist employment?
The essay says U.S. employment in word processors and typists fell from 985,000 in 1988 to about 40,400 in 2025, as word processors and personal computers changed office work.
Did the 1945 elevator strike cause automatic elevators to replace operators?
The strike is documented, but the essay says it found no evidence establishing that the strike caused the switch to operator-free elevators. That link remains a popular account rather than a confirmed fact.
What does the BLS projection say about office jobs?
According to the essay, an August 2026 BLS projection identified office and administrative support as the occupational group expected to shrink fastest through 2035, partly because of AI tools. The forecast is not a confirmed result.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
